
Mexican Coca-Cola has continued to gain popularity over the past few years, now even showing up in some supermarket chain stores. The growing cult following, myself included, have convinced ourselves that the use of natural cane sugar in Mexican Coke, instead of high fructose corn syrup in the American version, results in a far superior product.
Comparing the list of ingredients reveals the only obvious difference to be the use of the two different sweeteners. However, also on the list of ingredients in both products is the always nebulous “natural flavors”, which could also play a role in the difference.
I have been wanting to conduct a blind taste test for a while now, and finally did so last night.
What was most surprising to me was how very different they were when compared side by side: the Mexican Coke had a very distinctive “brown” cane sugar flavor, was very smooth, and lightly carbonated. American Coke was brighter, bubblier, more acidic with distinct citrus notes, and somehow had an aftertaste of artificial sweetener, like saccharin! I didn’t believe my palate at first, but after multiple tastes, this artificial sweetener taste kept showing up at the end of the sip.
The Mexican Coke reminds me of motel stops on road trips with my parents as a child. After checking in to our room, my dad and I would go down the hall, where there would often be an ice machine and one of those old school Coke machines, with ice cold bottles for a quarter. Back at the room, we would unwrap one of those “sanitized” glasses, add ice, and share an ice cold Coke. Pure bliss, especially on a hot summer day in the middle of nowhere! So, there are some powerful memories which I relate to the drink, and they are revived for me when I drink a Mexican Coke.
So, which one is better? I encourage you to do a taste test and decide for yourself.